Last Update November 13, 2026

How to Sell More on eBay With Best Offer: Start Conversations, Make Sales!

An eBay buyer sends you an offer. It’s lower than you’d like. Do you accept, decline, or counteroffer?

Before you hit that Decline button, consider this: That buyer just opened the door to a conversation that could lead to a sale! That’s why I’m a big fan of eBay’s Best Offer feature.

Best Offer gives shoppers the chance to negotiate. At the same time, it gives YOU the opportunity to turn interested buyers into paying customers.

And here’s what I especially love: You don’t have to accept every offer! Instead, you decide what works for your inventory, your business, and your profits. Let’s talk about how to make Best Offer work for you!

eBay Has Come a Long Way From Its Auction Days!

Remember when eBay was all about auctions?

Buyers loved the thrill of bidding and scoring a great deal. More than 30 years later, guess what? Buyers STILL love getting a bargain! Today, fixed-price listings dominate eBay. However, shoppers haven’t lost their love of negotiating.

That’s where Best Offer comes in!

When you enable Best Offer on an eligible listing, you invite shoppers to suggest a price they’re willing to pay.

From there, you can:

  • Accept an offer and make a sale.
  • Decline an offer that doesn’t work for you.
  • Counteroffer and keep the conversation going!

Best Offer is free to use, although regular selling fees still apply. Here’s something else worth remembering: Not every shopper will negotiate!

Some buyers will happily purchase your item at full price. Meanwhile, others enjoy making an offer. Either way, you’re giving buyers another reason to shop with you. More opportunities to make sales? I’m all for that!

3 Smart Ways to Make Best Offer Work for Your eBay Business

Before you start accepting offers, make sure you’ve done your homework!

1. Price Your Listings With Room to Negotiate

Here’s a strategy worth testing. Consider pricing your item 15% to 20% above the lowest amount you’re willing to accept, as long as your price remains competitive.

For example, let’s say you’d be happy to sell a jacket for $40. You might list it for $48. Now you’ve got some wiggle room when a buyer sends an offer!

However, don’t price your item so high that you scare away potential buyers. Instead, check comparable sold listings, understand what shoppers are willing to pay, and know your bottom line.

2. Don’t Forget About Shipping Costs!

If you offer free shipping, remember that YOU pay for shipping! Before accepting an offer, consider the item’s weight, package size, shipping destination, and estimated shipping costs.

For example, that $25 offer might sound terrific until you realize you’ll spend $12 shipping the item! You want sales. But more importantly, you want profits!

3. Factor In Your Promoted Listings Costs

Are you using eBay Promoted Listings? Advertising can help attract more shoppers to your listings. However, it also costs money!

Depending on the campaign you use and how eBay attributes the sale, you may pay additional advertising fees. Therefore, factor those costs into the lowest offer you’re willing to accept.

Remember, the goal isn’t just to make more sales. It’s to make profitable sales!

How to Set Up eBay Best Offer

Ready to give Best Offer a try? It’s easy! When creating or editing an eligible eBay listing:

  1. First, find the Pricing section.
  2. Next, turn on Allow offers.
  3. Then, decide whether to set a minimum offer amount or an Auto-Accept amount.
  4. Finally, review your settings and save your listing.

The exact steps may vary depending on which eBay listing tool you’re using. Most sellers use Best Offer with fixed-price listings. However, eBay also allows it on certain auction-style listings.

Now, let’s look at two settings that deserve your attention.

Auto-Accept: Let eBay Make the Sale for You!

I LOVE tools that save sellers time! With Auto-Accept, you tell eBay the price you’re happy to accept. Then, when a buyer submits an offer at or above that amount, eBay automatically accepts it.

For example, you list a sweater for $50 and set Auto-Accept at $45.

A buyer offers $46. Congratulations! eBay accepts the offer for you!

As a result, you don’t have to stop what you’re doing to review it. The buyer still needs to complete payment when applicable. Often eBay automatically processes the buyer’s payment.

Auto-Accept saves you time, while making you more money!

Auto-Decline: Are You Missing Opportunities to Make Sales?

Now, here’s where I want you to think about your selling strategy.

Auto-Decline automatically rejects offers below the minimum amount you set. Sounds convenient, right? And for sellers who receive lots of offers, it certainly can be!

However, consider this. You list a vintage lamp for $75. A shopper offers $45. Because you’ve set Auto-Decline at $50, eBay automatically declines that $45 offer.

But what if that shopper would have happily paid $60?

You may have missed an opportunity to start a conversation and make a sale! Instead of automatically declining lower offers, consider reviewing them yourself. That way, you can send a counteroffer and see whether the buyer is willing to meet you somewhere in the middle.

Of course, Auto-Decline isn’t always a poor choice. If you manage a large inventory and receive numerous offers, it can save valuable time. However, for many small and medium-sized eBay sellers, I encourage you to consider handling offers personally.

After all, an offer tells you that someone is interested in buying YOUR item. Why not explore that opportunity?

Should You Accept a Low Offer?

We’ve all been there! You list an item for $100. A buyer offers $35. Seriously?

Before automatically hitting Decline, consider the bigger picture.

  • How long have you had the item listed?
  • What did you originally pay for it?
  • How much space is it taking up?
  • Could you use the money to source inventory that sells faster?

Sometimes accepting a lower offer makes good business sense. For example, let’s say you’ve had a bulky item sitting in storage for eight months. A lower offer could free up valuable space and put money back into your business.

On the other hand, if you listed a desirable item yesterday and shoppers are showing plenty of interest, you might decide to hold out for a better price.

Every listing is different. Every buyer is different. And every selling decision deserves a little thought!

Above all, know your numbers and recognize opportunities when they come your way.

My Favorite Best Offer Strategy: Send a Counteroffer!

Here’s where Best Offer really shines! When a buyer makes an offer, they’ve already told you something important.

They’re interested in YOUR item!

That’s a terrific starting point. Instead of immediately declining an offer that’s too low, consider sending a counteroffer. For example, let’s say you’ve listed a beautiful dress for $80.

A buyer offers $50.

Although you don’t want to sell it for $50, you’d be happy with $65.  So, counteroffer at $65!

The buyer might accept. Alternatively, they might respond with another offer. Either way, you’ve created an opportunity to make a sale. And here’s something else to remember.

You don’t have to meet every buyer halfway! Instead, your counteroffer should reflect what makes sense for YOUR business.

Know your bottom line, protect your profits, and be willing to negotiate.

Add a Personal Note to Your Counteroffers!

Here’s another Best Offer tip I LOVE sharing with sellers! When eBay gives you the option to include a message with your counteroffer, USE IT!

Think of that little message as a mini sales pitch. It’s your opportunity to thank the shopper, reinforce your item’s value, and encourage them to buy. Best of all, it doesn’t have to be complicated!

Here’s an example:

“Thanks so much for your offer! I can do $65 on this beautiful dress. It’s in excellent condition and ready to ship. I’d love to make a deal with you!”

Friendly. Professional. And right to the point! You can even create a go-to message and personalize it for different items.

After all, there’s a real person on the other side of that offer!

A little kindness and friendly communication can go a long way.

Does Best Offer Help Your Listings Rank Higher in eBay Search?

Let’s talk about something every eBay seller cares about. Getting more shoppers to SEE your listings!

eBay uses Best Match as its default search-results order. And visibility matters!

After all, shoppers can’t buy your items if they never find them. Want more information on this? Check out my blog post, Best Offer Tips to Help You Sell More!

eBay Best Offer Tips to Help You Sell More! eBay seller coach Kathy Terrill smiles beside the eBay logo and a blue price tag graphic.

eBay Best Offer Tips To Help You Sell More!

You’ll also love the tips in my YouTube video, How to Sell More With eBay’s Best Offer!, I search for vintage oval mirrors. Interestingly, several listings near the top of the results include Best Offer. One organic listing even appears alongside sponsored listings.

Now, that doesn’t prove Best Offer automatically pushes listings higher in search. In fact, eBay considers multiple factors when ranking listings, including relevance, pricing, listing quality, and seller performance.

So, here’s what I encourage you to do.

Test Best Offer alongside other smart listing strategies!

For starters, use accurate titles, complete item specifics, competitive prices, and clear, attractive photos. Then track your results! Are you receiving more offers? Do offers turn into sales? Is your inventory turning into cash faster than before?

Ultimately, your results will help you decide what works best for YOUR business.

Don’t Just Decline an Offer. Start a Conversation!

eBay Best Offer: Start Conversations, Make More Sales! Smiling brunette woman shopping on a laptop, highlighting how Best Offer can help eBay sellers increase sales.

eBay Best Offer! Start Conversations. Make More Sales!

Here’s what I want you to remember.

Best Offer isn’t just about lowering prices. It’s about opening the door to more sales!

So, the next time an eBay buyer sends you an offer, don’t just look at the number.

Look at the opportunity!

After all, a friendly counteroffer could be all it takes to turn an interested shopper into your next sale.

Cha-ching!

About The Author

PHP Code Snippets Powered By : XYZScripts.com
Premier eBay Tips

Subscribe To Our Premier eBay Tips

Join our Premier eBay Tips to get the next practical tip for building a successful eBay business.

You have Successfully Subscribed!